Hootsgo
Published on Hootsgo (https://hootsgo.org)


Ketchup: Thick Or Thin?

In Drilling Fluid: The Lifeblood of the Well [1] you can read about the interesting properties of Visplex* drilling fluid. This fluid is a liquid while in motion, but when it is at rest it turns into a thick gel. This makes it useful because when the circulation of the drilling fluid stops, the gel suspends the rock cuttings and prevents them from sinking to the bottom of the borehole. Fluids, like Visplex, that become more viscous when standing still, such as Visplex, are called thixotropic.

Ketchup is another thixotropic liquid. Have you ever had trouble getting ketchup to come out of the bottle? You shake and shake but it's stuck. Then, once it gets going it flows quite freely. Ketchup that has been sitting still becomes thick. When it's shaken or stirred it becomes thinner. Here's a way to explore the thixotropic property of ketchup by seeing how rapidly weights fall through it.

Ketchup experiment

Tools and Materials

You will need:

  • Beaker full of ketchup at room temperature
  • Ring stand
  • Mirror
  • Several weights or steel balls. We used 10-g (0.35 oz) brass weights that came with our balance scale.
  • Spoon
  • Stopwatch.

What to Do

  1. Put the beaker on the ring stand with the mirror underneath as pictured to the right. The mirror lets you more easily see, without twisting your neck, when the weights reach the bottom.
  2. Drop a weight into the ketchup from just above the surface. Time how long it takes to reach the bottom.
  3. Drop and time four more weights the same way. Be careful not to drop a weight in the same spot where you previously put one. You want each weight to fall through undisturbed ketchup.
  4. Retrieve the weights with the spoon.
  5. Stir the ketchup thoroughly.
  6. Repeat steps 1 through 3. Use the chart below to record your results.
Trial Still ketchup Stirred ketchup

1

 
 

2

 
 

3

 
 

4

 
 

5

 
 

Average

 
 

 
Look at your results. Which is more viscous (thicker), still ketchup or stirred ketchup?

What are some good strategies for getting ketchup to flow easily out of the bottle?

You might also want to have a look at our results. [1]

Related Article

  • Results [2]
  • PDF Version of Experiment [3]

This content has been re-published with permission from SEED. Copyright © 2025 Schlumberger Excellence in Education Development (SEED), Inc.

Course: 

  • Science [4]
Result/Solution(s)

This chart shows the time it took, in seconds for 10-g brass weights to drop through to the bottom of a beaker of ketchup. We used 10-g weights because 20-g (0.70-oz) weights dropped through the ketchup very quickly and we had trouble timing them with the stopwatch. The 5-g (0.18-0z) weight wouldn't sink at all.

 

Time in seconds for 10 gram weights to sink to the bottom of a beaker of ketchup

Trial
Still ketchup

Stirred ketchup

1 5.34 4.38
2 7.84 4.00
3 6.72 4.75
4 8.53 4.19
5 10.75 5.81
Average >7.44 4.65

The results in the first column were with ketchup that had been sitting still for about an hour. Then we stirred the ketchup vigorously for a minute or so and tested it again. The results of this test are shown in the second column.

Try this...

Can you find weights that are suspended in still ketchup but sink in stirred ketchup?

  • viscosity [5]
  • liquid [6]
19128
Copyright © 2018 Hootsgo. All Rights Reserved. Hootsgo is a registered 501 (c) (3) non-profit organization.
Donated by Dev2Source I.T. Services Ltd.

Source URL: https://hootsgo.org/?q=ketchup-thick-or-thin&qt-quicktabs=1

Links
[1] https://hootsgo.org/node/8940
[2] https://hootsgo.org/relatedarticle/results-8
[3] https://hootsgo.org/sites/default/files/flash/science/features/airspace/cosmos/universe/pdf/ketchup.pdf
[4] https://hootsgo.org/?q=taxonomy/term/63
[5] https://hootsgo.org/?q=tags/viscosity
[6] https://hootsgo.org/?q=tags/liquid